top of page
dial800-every-connection-pdmi[81].png

ADVERTISEMENT

PDMI-Membership-stronger-together-square
PDMI-Membership-square-2.png
MSC AGENCY 1020x1020-3-v1.png

Part II: Your Ad Sent the Customer to Amazon: Is That a Problem?

10 minutes ago
3 min read

By Ranjit Mulgaonkar and Maya Mulgaonkar


Flatworld logo


In the September issue of the PDMI’s Results Magazine, you read the first part of this deep dive into how Amazon can best boost your D2C campaign. Continue below to read why Amazon converts so well, the tradeoffs marketers make by using Amazon, and more.


Why Amazon Converts So Well

Amazon’s biggest advantage is not just traffic. It removes friction from the purchase.

Consumers know how checkout works. Reviews provide reassurance. Shipping expectations are clear. Prime makes the decision even easier.

Amazon also captures people with strong purchase intent. A shopper may remember only part of the brand name — or simply the problem shown in the commercial. A well-managed listing can turn that partial memory into a sale.

An authorized Amazon presence also gives a brand more control over its listings, product images, pricing, and inventory. Note that leaving Amazon does not always make the product disappear. Your listing stays active even if you stop selling on Amazon. Any distributors or resellers with inventory can link to your listing and start selling your brand. You have no control on price and customer experience in this case.

For a nationally advertised product, Amazon can do three important jobs: capture demand, make buying easier, and protect the brand’s presence on the platform.

 

What the Brand Gives Up

The biggest trade-off is customer ownership.

On its own website, a brand can — with the proper consent — collect email addresses and mobile numbers, introduce subscriptions, recommend related products, and build a loyalty program. It can also track customer lifetime value across multiple purchases.

Amazon provides useful, aggregated information about searches, demographics, and repeat purchases. But it does not give brands an unrestricted customer list for remarketing.

Put simply, a brand can own a permissioned customer relationship on its D2C site. On Amazon, it rents access to a highly effective shopping experience.

Customer data should not be overvalued. A large database is worth little if customers buy once and ignore future messages. Brands should measure the actual profit created by email, SMS, subscriptions, and repeat purchases.

Amazon can also create pricing conflicts. A discount may cause problems with Walmart, Target, Home Depot, Lowe’s, dealers, or the brand’s own website. Amazon also places your product beside cheaper alternatives, sponsored competitors, and customer reviews. On TV, the brand controls the story. On Amazon, it becomes one option in a comparison.

 

Don’t Keep Flipping the Amazon Switch

Some brands turn Amazon on to capture volume, turn it off to push shoppers toward D2C, and return when sales fall.

That strategy can hurt search rankings, advertising efficiency, inventory planning, and momentum. An unavailable Amazon listing does not necessarily send shoppers to the brand’s website. It may send them to a competitor.

The solution? Give each channel a clear role.

Amazon might carry the hero product or a simplified offer. The D2C site could feature premium bundles, subscriptions, accessories, personalization, or extended service. Retailers could receive assortments designed for their customers.

This gives shoppers a real reason to choose one channel over another while reducing direct price comparisons.

Without an Amazon strategy, you risk losing a sale to another seller with an active offer at the expense of your external ad spend.

 

Ranjit Mulgaonkar is CEO and Maya Mulgaonkar is senior vice president of client services of Flatworld Group, an Amazon and TikTok Shop agency. They can be reached via email, respectively, at ranjit@flatworldgroup.com and maya@flatworldgroup.com.

Mailing Address: 23052 Alicia Pkwy # H-172
Mission Viejo, CA 92692

​

Email: cust_svc@definitivemediagroup.com

Phone: (949) 273-6231

​​

Reproduction — in whole or in part — is prohibited without written permission.

​

The PDMI manages and maintains all of its own lists, including event attendee lists. Any authentic outreach you may receive regarding the PDMI's member or attendee mailing lists will come directly from PDMI staff only.

​

©2026 Definitive Media Group. All rights reserved.

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Youtube
bottom of page